« Forum index · Mulholland Dr.

Ruth's Closet

User avatar
andthendougsaid
Posts: 22

Ruth's Closet

by andthendougsaid » 05 Nov 2010

When Rita opens the closet to get the blue box, while the clothes and everything else seem to be the same as before, the suitcases on the floor appear different, and at least one is much shorter.

Here are the original suitcases: second.pngsecond2.png

And here they are (much clearer) later on donde.png

Perhaps this is just a continuity error, but could it be an indication that Aunt Ruth has already "returned"? I can't think of any interesting interpretations. Of course, these bags are much smaller than the ones she put in the taxi at the beginning, so it doesn't make much sense for her to have moved them even if she'd been around. Either way, the woman seems to have quite a bit of luggage.

User avatar
andthendougsaid
Posts: 22

Re: Ruth's Closet

by andthendougsaid » 05 Nov 2010

Those are some interesting ideas. It might also be worthwhile to note the relative positions of the picture frame and clock in the pictures above and these ones...

first.pngruth.png

The ones from my original post go between these. The picture frame is right behind Rita in the "donde" screenshot. I'm unable to make out the clock in the last shot of the nightstand, but in general the two pieces seem to be gradually trading places.

User avatar
Cowboy
Posts: 47

Re: Ruth's Closet

by Cowboy » 06 Nov 2010

andthendougsaid wrote:Perhaps this is just a continuity error, but could it be an indication that Aunt Ruth has already "returned"? I can't think of any interesting interpretations. Of course, these bags are much smaller than the ones she put in the taxi at the beginning, so it doesn't make much sense for her to have moved them even if she'd been around. Either way, the woman seems to have quite a bit of luggage.


Nice observation! I love that sort of thing.

Lynch is known as a bit of a perfectionist yet there seems to be enough continuity errors in the film to make one ponder ... what's going on? :scratch:
Well, stop for a little second and think about it. Can you do that for me?